Current trends in engineering globalization require researchers to revisit various normalized standards that determine “best practices” in industries. This paper presents comparative analysis of tooth-root strength evaluation methods used within ISO and AGMA standards and verifying them with developed models and simulations using the finite element method (FEM). The presented analysis is conducted for (1) wide range of spur and helical gears manufactured using racks or gear tools; and for (2) various combinations of key geometrical (gear design), manufacturing (racks and gear tools), and performance (load location) parameters. FEM of tooth-root strength is performed for each modeled gear. FEM results are compared with stresses calculated based on the ISO and AGMA standards. The comparative analysis for various combinations of design, manufacturing, and performance parameters are illustrated graphically and discussed briefly. The results will allow for a better understanding of existing limitations in the current standards applied in engineering practice as well as provide a basis for future improvements and/or unifications of gear standards.
1.
Ceglarek
, D.
, Huang
, W.
, Zhou
, S.
, Ding
, Y.
, Kumar
, R.
, and Zhou
, Y.
, 2004, “Time-Based Competition in Manufacturing: Stream-of-Variation Analysis (SOVA) Methodology—Review
,” Int. J. of Flexible Manuf. Syst.
, 16
(1
), pp. 11
–44
.2.
Anderson
, N.
et al., 2004, “Gear Industry Vision. A Vision of Gear Industry in 2025
,” Technical Report developed at the Gear Industry Vision Workshop, March 10, 2004, Detroit. The report was prepared by Energetics, Inc., and sponsored by U.S. Army, AGMA Foundation, ASME CRTD, Ben Franklin Technology Center, Boeing, Gleason Foundation, GM, and John Deere.3.
Dudley
, D. W.
, 2002, Handbook of Practical Gear Design
, CRC
, Boca Raton, FL
.4.
Townsend
, D. P.
, 1992, Dudley’s Gear Handbook
, McGraw–Hill
, New York
.5.
Smith
, J. D.
, 1999, Gear Noise and Vibration
, Dekker
, New York
.6.
Badgley
, R. H.
, and Hartman
, R. H.
, 1974, “Gearbox Noise Reduction: Prediction and Measurement of Mesh-Frequency Vibrations Within an Operating Helicopter Rotor-Drive Gearbox
,” Trans. ASME J. Eng. Ind.
, 96
(2
), pp. 567
–577
.7.
Cavdar
, K.
, Karpat
, F.
, and Babalik
, F. C.
, 2005, “Computer Aided Analysis of Bending Strength of Involute Spur Gears with Asymmetric Profile
,” ASME J. Mech. Des.
1050-0472, 127
(3
), pp. 477
–484
.8.
Wang
, M.-J.
, 2003, “A New Photoelastic Investigation of the Dynamic Bending Stress of Spur Gears
,” ASME J. Mech. Des.
1050-0472, 125
(2
), pp. 365
–372
.9.
Velex
, P.
, and Baud
, S.
, 2002, “Static and Dynamic Tooth Loading in Spur and Helical Geared Systems—Experiments and Model Validation
,” ASME J. Mech. Des.
1050-0472, 124
(2
), pp. 334
–346
.10.
Winter
, H.
, and Hirt
, M.
, 1974, “Zahnfußtragfähigkeit auf der Grundlage der Wirklichen Spannungen. Spannungskorrekturfaktor, Kerbempfindlichkeitszahl und Relativer Kerbfaktor in ISO-Ansatz
,” VDI-Z
, 116
(2
), pp. 119
–126
.11.
Linke
, H.
, and Sporbert
, K.
, 1985, “Einfluß des Schleifabsatzes auf die Spannungs-Konzentration bei Verzahnungen
,” Maschinenbautechnik
, 34
(4
), pp. 251
–257
.12.
Jaśkiewicz
, Z.
, and Wąsiewski
, A.
, 1992, Spur Gear Transmissions. Geometry, Strength, Accuracy of Manufacturing
(in Polish), 1
, Transport and Communication
, Warsaw
.13.
Jaśkiewicz
, Z.
, and Wąsiewski
, A.
, 1995, Spur Gear Transmissions. Design
(in Polish), 2
, Transport and Communication
, Warsaw
.14.
Litvin
, F. L.
, Egelja
, A.
, Tan
, J.
, and Heath
, G.
, 1998, “Computerized Design, Generation and Simulation of Meshing of Orthogonal Offset Face-Gear Drive With a Spur Involute Pinion With Localized Bearing Contact
,” Mech. Mach. Theory
0094-114X, 33
(1/2
), pp. 87
–102
.15.
Pedrero
, J. I.
, Rueda
, A.
, and Fuentes
, A.
, 1999, “Determination of the ISO Tooth Form Factor for Involute Spur and Helical Gears
,” Mech. Mach. Theory
0094-114X, 34
(1
), pp. 89
–103
.16.
Bathe
, K. J.
, 1996, Finite Element Procedures
, Prentice–Hall
, Englewood Cliffs, NJ
.17.
Kleiber
, M.
, ed., 1998, Handbook of Computational Solid Mechanics
, Springer
, Berlin
.18.
Weck
, M.
, 1992, Moderne Leistungsgetriebe. Verzahnungsauslegung und Betriebsverhalten
, Springer-Verlag
, Berlin
.19.
Guingand
, M.
, de Vaujany
, J. P.
, and Icard
, Y.
, 2004, “Fast Three-Dimensional Quasi-Static Analysis of Helical Gears Using the Finite Prism Method
,” ASME J. Mech. Des.
1050-0472, 126
(6
), pp. 1082
–1088
.20.
Sainsot
, P.
, and Velex
, P.
, 2004, “Contribution of Gear Body to Tooth Deflections—A New Bidimensional Analytical Formula
,” ASME J. Mech. Des.
1050-0472, 126
(4
), pp. 748
–752
.21.
Litvin
, F. L.
, Fuentes
, A.
, Zani
, C.
, Pontiggia
, M.
, and Handschuh
, R. F.
, 2002, “Face-Gear Drive With Spur Involute Pinion: Geometry, Generation by a Worm, Stress Analysis
,” Comput. Methods Appl. Mech. Eng.
0045-7825, 191
(25–26
), pp. 2785
–2813
.22.
Litvin
, F. L.
, Chen
, J. S.
, Lu
, J.
, Handschuh
, R. F.
, 1996, “Application of Finite Element Analysis for Determination of Load Share, Real Contact Ratio, Precision of Motion, and Stress Analysis
,” ASME J. Mech. Des.
1050-0472, 118
(4
), pp. 561
–567
.23.
Lewicki
, D. G.
, Handschuh
, R. F.
, Spievak
, L. E.
, Wawrzynek
, P. A.
, and Ingraffea
, A. R.
, 2001, “Consideration of Moving Tooth Load in Gear Crack Propagation Predictions
,” ASME J. Mech. Des.
1050-0472, 123
(1
), pp. 118
–124
.24.
Handschuh
, R. F.
, and Bibel
, G. D.
, 1999, “Experimental and Analytical Study of Aerospace Spiral Bevel Gear Tooth Fillet Stresses
,” ASME J. Mech. Des.
1050-0472, 121
(4
), pp. 565
–572
.25.
Barkah
, D.
, Shafiq
, B.
, and Dooner
, D.
, 2002, “3D Mesh Generation for Static Stress Determination in Spiral Noncircular Gears Used for Torque Balancing
,” ASME J. Mech. Des.
1050-0472, 124
(2
), pp. 313
–319
.26.
Liu
, L.
, and Pines
, D. J.
, 2002, “The Influence of Gear Design Parameters on Gear Tooth Damage Detection Sensitivity
,” ASME J. Mech. Des.
1050-0472, 124
(4
), pp. 794
–804
.27.
ISO 6336 Standard, Calculation of Load Capacity of Spur and Helical Gears.
28.
DIN 3990, Tragfähigkeitsberechnung von Stirnrädern, Dezember 1987.
29.
AGMA 908-B89, April 1989, Geometry Factors for Determining the Pitting Resistance and Bending Strength of Spur, Helical and Herringbone Gear Teeth.
30.
AGMA 918-A93. AGMA Information Sheet, January 1993, A Summary of Numerical Examples Demonstrating the Procedures for Calculating Geometry Factors for Spur and Helical Gears.
31.
ANSI/AGMA 6002-B93, February 1993, Design Guide for Vehicle Spur and Helical Gears.
32.
ANSI/AGMA 2001-C95, January 1995, Fundamental Rating Factors and Calculation Methods for Involute Spur and Helical Gear Teeth.
33.
ANSI/AGMA 2101-C95, January 1995, Metric Edition of ANSI/AGMA 2001-C95. Fundamental Rating Factors and Calculation Methods for Involute Spur and Helical Gear Teeth.
34.
ANSI/AGMA 6110-F97, September 1997, Standard for Spur, Helical, Herringbone and Bevel Enclosed Drives. Annex C, Illustrative examples.
35.
AGMA Information Sheet 913-A98, Method for Specifying the Geometry of Spur and Helical Gears.
36.
Hösel
, T.
, 1988, “Einfluß der Zahnform auf die Flanken—und Zahnfuβtragfähigkeit nach DIN 3990 und AGMA 218.01—Grenzen für Optimierungsrechnungen
,” Antriebstechnik
, 27
(9
), pp. 65
–68
.37.
Hösel
, T.
, 1989, “Vergleich der Tragfähigkeitsberechnung für Stirnräder nach ANSI/AGMA—ISO/DIN—und RGW-Normen
,” Antriebstechnik
, 28
(11
), pp. 77
–84
.38.
Niemann
, G.
, and Winter
, H.
, 1985, Maschinenelemente, Band II
, Springer-Verlag
, Berlin
.39.
Lewicki
, D. G.
, and Ballarini
, R.
, 1997, “Gear Crack Propagation Investigations
,” Gear Technol.
0743-6858, 14
(6
), pp. 18
–24
.40.
Kawalec
, A.
, and Wiktor
, J.
, 1999, “Analytical and Numerical Method of Determination of Spur Gear Tooth Profile Machined by Gear Tools
,” Adv. Technol. Mach. Equipment
, 23
(2
), pp. 5
–28
.41.
Math
, V. B.
, and Chand
, S.
, 2004, “An Approach to the Determination of Spur Gear Tooth Root Fillet
,” ASME J. Mech. Des.
1050-0472, 126
(2
), pp. 336
–340
.42.
ADINA Theory and Modeling Guide
, ADINA R & D, Inc.
, Watertown, MA
, 2000.43.
Kawalec
, A.
, 1997, “Modelling of Tooth Flanks Based on Distorted Measurements
,” Adv. Technol. Mach. Mech. Equipment
, 21
(3
), pp. 5
–28
.44.
Kawalec
, A.
, and Wiktor
, J.
, 2001, “Analysis of Strength of Tooth Root With Notch After Finishing of Involute Gears
,” Arch. Mech. Eng.
, 48
(3
), pp. 217
–248
.45.
Timoshenko
, S. P.
, and Goodyear
, J. N.
, 1970, Theory of Elasticity
, McGraw–Hill
, New York
.46.
Kramberger
, J.
, Šraml
, M.
, Potrč
, I.
, and Flašker
, J.
, 2004, “Numerical Calculation of Bending Fatigue Life of Thin-Rim Spur Gears
,” Eng. Fract. Mech.
0013-7944, 71
(4–6
), pp. 647
–656
.47.
Li
, S.
, 2002, “Gear Contact Model and Loaded Tooth Contact Analysis of a Three-Dimensional Thin-Rimmed Gear
,” ASME J. Mech. Des.
1050-0472, 124
(3
), pp. 511
–517
.48.
Ceglarek
, DS.
, Shi
, J.
, and Wu
, S. M.
, 1994, “A Knowledge-based Diagnosis Approach for the Launch of the Auto-body Assembly Process
,” ASME J. Eng. Ind.
0022-0817, 116
(4
), pp. 491
–499
.49.
Rybak
, J.
, Kawalec
, A.
, and Wiktor
, J.
, 1999, “Analysis in Involute Cylindrical Gear Transmissions with Modified Tooth Trace
,” Proceedings of the 4th World Congress on Gearing and Power Transmissions
, Paris, M.C.I., 1
, pp. 169
–181
.Copyright © 2006
by American Society of Mechanical Engineers
You do not currently have access to this content.
