Many nuclear steam generators have accumulated more than 10 effective-full-power-years of operation. Eddy-current inspections revealed that a number of these steam generator tubes, notably those located in high local cross-flow regions, have indications of wear at some support plate elevations after 5 to 10 yr of effective-full-power operations. In the last 5 yr, a number of technical papers on nonlinear tube bundle dynamics has been published to address the effect of tube and support plate interactions. At the same time, test data relating wear and tube wall thickness losses for different material combinations and different support plate geometries became available. Based on the available data in the literature, as well as data obtained in the author’s affiliation, this paper assesses the cumulative tube wall wear after 5, 10, and 15 effective-full-power years of operation of a typical commercial nuclear steam generator, using different wear models. It is hoped that this study will shed some light on the probable mechanism that caused the observed wear in today’s operating nuclear steam generators.

Issue Section:
Research Papers
Topics:
Boilers, Flow (Dynamics), Wear, Nuclear reactor steam generators, Cross-flow, Dynamics (Mechanics), Eddy current testing, Elevations (Drawings), Wall thickness
1.
Axisa, F., and Izquierdo, P., 1992, “Experiments on Vibro-Impact Dynamics of Loosely Supported Tubes Under Harmonics Excitation,” Proceedings, International Symposium on Flow-Induced Vibration and Noise, Vol. 2, ASME PVP-Vol. 242, eds., M. J. Paidoussis, S. S. Chen, and D. A. Steininger.
2.
Axisa
F.
,
Antunes
J.
, and
Villard
B.
,
1988
, “
Overview of Numerical Methods for Predicting Flow-Induced Vibration
,”
ASME JOURNAL OF PRESSURE VESSEL TECHNOLOGY
, Vol.
110
, pp.
6
–
14
.
3.
Axisa, F., et al., 1986, “Flow-Induced Vibration of Steam Generator Tubes,” EPRI Report NP-4559.
4.
Boucher, K. M., and Taylor, C. E., 1996, “Tube Support Effectiveness and Wear Damage Assessment in the U-bend Region of Nuclear Steam Generators,” Flow-Induced Vibration—1996, ASME PVP-Vol. 328, ed., M. J. Pettigrew.
5.
Boucher, K. M., 1995, “OTSG Fluidelastic Instability Study for a Drilled Hole Tube Support Plate,” AECL Research Report.
6.
Brenneman, B., and Gurdal, R. J., 1997, “A Time Domain Formulation and Solution of Fluidelastic Instability in Steam Generator Tube Bundles,” presented at the 4th International Symposium on Flow-Induced Vibration and Noise, Dallas, TX.
7.
Fisher, N. J., Chow, A. B., and Weckwerth, M. K., 1994, “Experimental Fretting-Wear Studies of Steam Generator Materials,” ASME PVP-Vol. 273, Flow-Induced Vibration—1994 ed., M. K. Au-Yang.
8.
Fisher, N. J., Ing, J. G., Pettigrew, M. J., and Rogers, R. J., 1992, “Tube-to-Support Dynamics of a Multi-span Steam Generator Tube,” Proceedings, International Symposium on Flow-Induced Vibration and Noise, Vol. 2, ASME PVP-Vol. 242, eds., M. J. Paidoussis, S. S. Chen, and D. A. Steininger.
9.
Guerout, F. M., Fisher, N. J., Grandison, D. A., and Weckwerth, M. K., 1996, “Effect of Temperature on Steam Generator Fretting Wear,” Flow-Induced Vibration—1996, ASME PVP-Vol. 328, ed., M. J. Pettigrew.
10.
Hofmann, P. J., and Schettler, T., 1989, “PWR Steam Generator Tube Fretting and Fatigue Wear,” EPRI Report NP-6341.
11.
Kawamura, K., Yasuo, A., and Inada, F., 1991, “Tube-to-Support Dynamic Interaction and Wear of Heat Exchanger Tubes Caused by Turbulent Flow-Induced Vibration,” ASME PVP-Vol. 206, Flow-Induced Vibration and Wear—1991, eds., M. K. Au-Yang and F. Hara.
12.
Ko, P. L., et al., 1996, “Friction and Wear Studies of Nuclear Power Plant Components in Pressurized High Temperature Water Environments,” Flow-Induced Vibrations—1996, ASME Vol. 328, ed., M. J. Pettigrew.
13.
Ko, P. L., 1993, “Wear due to Flow-Induced Vibration,” Technology for the 90s, ASME Special Publication, ed., M. K. Au-Yang.
14.
Payen, T., Villard, B., and Jalaldeen, S., 1995, “Experimental Validation of Tube-to-Support Impact Computations in Cross-Flow,” Proceedings, 6th International Conference on Flow-Induced Vibration, London, UK, pp. 404–411.
15.
Rao, M. S. M., Steininger, D. A., and Eisinger, F. L., 1988, “Numerical Simulation of Fluidelastic Vibration and Wear of Multi-span Tubes With Clearance at Supports,” ASME Proceedings, Second International Symposium on Flow-Induced Vibration and Noise, Vol. 5, eds., M. J. Paidoussis et al.
16.
Sauve´, R. G., 1996, “A Computational Time Domain Approach to Fluidelastic Instability for Nonlinear Tube Dynamics,” Flow-Induced Vibration—1996, ASME PVP-Vol. 328, ed., M. J. Pettigrew.
17.
Taylor, C. E., Bourcher, K. M., and Yetisir, M., 1995, “Vibration and Impact Forces Due to Two-Phase Cross Flow in U-Bend Region of Heat Exchangers,” Proceedings, 6th International Conference on Flow-Induced Vibration, London, UK, pp. 404–411.
18.
US NRC, 1988, US Nuclear Regulatory Commission Bulletin 88-02.
19.
Yetisir, M., and Fisher, N. J., “Fretting Wear Prediction in Heat Exchanger Tubes—Effect of Chemical Cleaning,” Flow-Induced Vibration—1996, ASME PVP-Vol. 328, ed., M. J. Pettigrew.
This content is only available via PDF.
Copyright © 1998
 by The American Society of Mechanical Engineers
You do not currently have access to this content.